The college volleyball world is grappling with intense debate after a viral video showed San Jose State University’s Blaire Fleming, reportedly a transgender athlete, spiking a ball that hit San Diego State player Keira Herron in the face. The incident has drawn sharp attention online, with the Independent Council on Women’s Sports (ICONS) and others calling for the NCAA to reevaluate eligibility policies for transgender athletes. Fleming has become a controversial figure, with four teams reportedly forfeiting matches against San Jose State over concerns about safety and competitive fairness.
ICONS, an advocacy group, has filed a federal lawsuit citing safety concerns surrounding Fleming, with Fleming’s teammate Brooke Slusser joining the complaint. Slusser alleges that she was discouraged by the school from voicing safety concerns related to gender identity issues.
San Jose State coach Todd Kress acknowledged the controversy’s impact on his team, stating, “Outside forces have sought to divide our team… It’s weighing on the players who have put in years of hard work.” He expressed concerns about the mental health effects on student-athletes facing harassment.
How is this allowed?? When do we say enough??!! @NCAA
— Beth Bourne (@bourne_beth2345) October 11, 2024
Watch the massive blow by Blaire Fleming, a male player, to the face of a woman on San Diego State's team. Announcer even expresses his disbelief as her face turns pink from the impact. @icons_women @Riley_Gaines_… pic.twitter.com/DeoChrjIOn
The university has declined to address the gender identity of any player, citing FERPA protections, and stated that its program complies fully with NCAA and Mountain West Conference regulations. For now, the debate over inclusion and safety in college sports remains as intense as ever, leaving San Jose State navigating a challenging season amid nationwide scrutiny.
