As the Toronto Maple Leafs push deeper into their Stanley Cup window, fans are buzzing over a proposed trade that could bring back former Leaf Michael Bunting, along with Penguins’ forward Drew O’Connor. This fan-driven idea on PuckPedia’s PuckGM tool suggests Toronto could send Timothy Liljegren, Nick Robertson, and a first-round pick to Pittsburgh in exchange for the gritty duo, adding depth and intensity to their lineup.
Bringing Bunting back to Toronto would reintroduce a player who quickly became a fan favorite for his aggressive playstyle and offensive contributions. Bunting racked up 112 points in 161 games during his two seasons with the Leafs before departing in free agency. After signing with the Carolina Hurricanes, he found himself with the Penguins via a mid-season trade, where he’s continued to show his scoring and physicality. O’Connor, a versatile winger, would be a valuable asset for Toronto’s third or fourth line, bringing experience and a scoring touch.
In exchange, the Leafs would send two valuable pieces. Liljegren, a former first-round pick, has struggled to cement a spot under new coach Craig Berube, who has openly critiqued the defenseman’s need to “simplify his game” and be “heavier in battles.” NHL insider Elliotte Friedman even reported that Toronto is actively exploring a trade for Liljegren, who’s currently down in the depth chart. Robertson, who’s shown flashes of potential, requested a trade in the offseason but signed a one-year deal to compete for a spot. Pittsburgh could give Robertson a fresh start in a top-six role, while Liljegren could find a more defined role on their blue line.
Tensions between the two teams have already surfaced, with Bunting’s notorious penalty-drawing tactics getting under the skin of Leafs defenseman Simon Benoit in their October 12 matchup. Benoit bluntly called Bunting a “diver” after the game, adding fuel to the rivalry.
Would this trade help Toronto solidify its roster for a Cup run? Or should the Leafs hold off and wait for a bigger move? Fans and analysts alike are divided, but one thing is clear: Toronto’s lineup could get a serious shake-up if this trade goes through.
