After a crushing World Series loss, the New York Yankees are laser-focused on one mission: keeping Juan Soto in pinstripes. The Dominican superstar’s breakout postseason has made him an indispensable piece of the Yankees’ puzzle. But as Soto publicly declared he’s open to negotiations with any team this offseason, the Yankees face the gut-wrenching reality that he might walk away.
With seven deep-pocketed teams ready to woo Soto, Yankees GM Brian Cashman is under immense pressure to devise a Plan B. And one name that’s surfaced as a potential replacement is none other than Mets star slugger Pete Alonso. But not everyone is sold on the idea of Alonso as a fit for the Bronx Bombers—including broadcaster Michael Kay, who questions the logic of bringing in a 30-year-old first baseman for a hefty, long-term contract.
Kay’s skepticism resonates with fans who see Alonso’s Mets allegiance and recent struggles as potential red flags. “I appreciate Pete Alonso as a player, but why would the Yankees do that?” Kay argued. “A right-handed batter that they’re going to have to spend six-to-seven years for. He’s 30 years old; why would you do that?”
While Alonso has undeniable power and a loyal Mets following, his acquisition wouldn’t be seamless. Plus, if the Mets manage to land Soto, they may not feel inclined to retain Alonso, making him available—but at what cost? The Yankees may have other considerations, especially with questions around Alonso’s age and recent form.
Enter Nolan Arenado: The Yankees’ Potential Left-Field Solution?
Kay’s alternative for filling a Soto-sized hole is St. Louis Cardinals’ third baseman Nolan Arenado, whose skills, both defensively and offensively, make him a potential cornerstone for the Yankees’ infield and lineup. Arenado, an elite third baseman with consistent power at the plate, could bring stability and star power that Cashman desperately needs if Soto departs.
At 33, Arenado might not be as young as Soto, but his baseball IQ, stellar defense, and right-handed power could align with the Yankees’ vision of a formidable roster. And while Arenado doesn’t bring the left-handed bat the Yankees might prefer in their lineup, his proven consistency and leadership could make him an asset in New York.
As the offseason heats up, the Yankees face tough decisions. Will they pull out all the stops to retain Soto, or will they go all-in on a blockbuster trade for Arenado? In any case, Cashman’s next move will define the Yankees’ roster and possibly their future as contenders. Stay tuned—this offseason promises to be a defining one for Yankees Nation.
